• Best Films of 2015
    • Katherine and Matt's Individual Rankings: 2014
  • Best Films, 2012-2014
    • The Iron List Top 10 of 2012 >
      • Katherine and Matt's Individual Rankings: 2012
    • The Iron List Top 15 of 2013
  • Best Films, 2010-2011
    • Katherine's Top 32 of 2011
    • Matt's Top 10 of 2011
    • Matt's Bottom 29 of 2011
    • Matt's Top 5 of 2010
    • Matt's Second 5 of 2010
  • Films of the Decade (2000-2009)
    • MASTER LIST TOP TEN >
      • Films #25 to #11
      • Films #50 to #26
      • Films #75 to #51
      • Films #100 --> #76
    • Matt's Top 100 >
      • MATT'S TOP TEN
      • Films #25 to #11
      • Films #50 to #26
      • Films #75 to #51
      • Films #100 to #76
    • Katherine's Top 100 >
      • KATHERINE'S TOP TEN
      • Films #25 to #11
      • Films #50 to #26
      • Films #75 to #51
      • Films #100 to #76
    • Your Individual Lists >
      • List-Making Resources
  • Blog
@Khill0, @karpmj

All-Quarterfinals Starting XI

6/30/2010

31 Comments

 
Picture
Kingson vs. Ozil in the only all-quarterfinal meeting of the Cup so far.
With two full days before the first quarterfinal match is played, we have world and time enough to think about the tournament as a whole.  Today, then, I present my All-Quarterfinals Starting XI.  Before we begin, here are my four self-imposed rules for this exercise:

1. Players can only be chosen from the eight quarterfinal teams.

2. The selections are based solely on their form in this tournament, not incoming reputations (though obviously these biases are hard to dislodge).

3. The players should be chosen to play as a team.  This is not simply the most spectacular 11 individuals in the Cup so far; it's a lineup that, in theory at least, could function successfully as a unit.

4. At least one player from every team should be included.  Otherwise why not just trot out Team Brazil, tack on Villa and Messi, and call it a day?

On to the XI! (And I'd love, by the way, to hear your comments and/or alternate Quarterfinal XIs below...)
Picture
I'm playing a modified 4-4-2, or what basically amounts to a 4-1-3-2.  (Note: is there anything -- really, anything? -- geekier than a detailed parsing of soccer tactical formations?  "Come on, that's not a real 3-4-3-1, you fraud, it's just a plain ol' 4-3-1-2 with a cherry on top!")

Goalkeeper: Richard Kingson, Ghana. I know there's a meme in club football that African goalkeepers haven't quite measured up to world-class level.  Maybe it's a consistency thing; and maybe it's just racism, but whatever the case that seems crazy to me as a World Cup viewer.  Nigeria's Vincent Enyeama has probably been the best pure-shot stopper of the Cup, and Richard Kingson is a close second.  Though he's only the third-string keeper for mediocre Wigan Athletic, Kingson leads the quarterfinal keepers with 17 saves and has let in just 3 goals -- one via a penalty kick.  And it's not just spectacular one-on-one stuff (like his save on Ozil, above): his positioning vs. the USA was excellent, with Findley, Bornstein, and Feilhaber, among others, finding their open-goal shots swallowed up in his torso (yeah, yeah, insert anti-US striker joke here).

Left Back: Joan Capdevila, Spain.  This was actually the toughest spot to fill: in a quarterfinal loaded with explosive right backs (Maicon, Sergio Ramos, Philip Lahm, even Ghana's John Pantsil), fewer left backs have stood out.  But Capdevila has been unflappable on defense, and consistently useful in attack; in fact, the amalgamated stat-makers behind the Castrol Rankings declare him the top-rated player in all tournament so far.  I don't trust their methodology too well -- Steven Gerrard, really? -- but it's enough for me to slot Capdevila in my starting XI.

Center Back: Diego Lugano, Uruguay.  Not just because he looks like Brooke Shields's youthful companion in The Blue Lagoon. Lugano is also the captain and obvious leader of one of the tournament's best defenses, conceding just one goal in four matches so far.  A fiery, active center back, he's tenacious on the ball and tall enough (at 6-1) to win challenges in the air.  Few defenders have looked more formidable so far in 2010.

Picture
Alcaraz: an alcazar of the Parguayan defense.
Center Back: Antolin Alcaraz, Paraguay. Yes, an all-Guay center backfield, but it's no less than than they've deserved for their steeliness all tournament long.  Alcaraz, rated the Cup's #3 overall player by Castol, also scored Paraguay's crucial goal in the opening game against Italy.  During ESPN's halftime show, his Wigan manager Roberto Martinez has been drooling over him since the games began, and now, after four complete defensive performances, we can see why.  (Two Wigan players in the Quarterfinals XI?  You better believe it.)

Right Back: Maicon, Brazil.  At one of the tournament's top positions (see above), this is still an easy choice.  Maicon, perhaps even more than Kaka, is the engine that makes Brazil's attacking gears churn.  Bursting up and down that right flank, he often seems affixed to the upper corner of the opponent's 18-yard box, but I haven't once seen him exposed for a mis-timed forward adventure. He won and then fired in the perfect corner that set up Brazil's game-breaking first goal against Chile.  And, of course, his 55th minute side-slotted masterpiece against North Korea is probably the most memorable goal of the tournament so far. 

Picture
MVB: like Martin Van Buren, but tall.
Holding Midfield: Mark Van Bommel, Netherlands.  As Zonal Marking notes, Van Bommel is perhaps the man of the Cup for the Dutch, and that says a lot about the style they've played.  Perfectly comfortable with the ball, Van Bommel is a tireless runner and truculent tackler without it.  This combination of placid possession and energetic ball-pressure has helped the Dutch dominate the midfield in all four games so far; and if they are to hold the line against Brazil on Friday, Van Bommel will need to remain at the center of things.

Right (Wing) Midfield: Thomas Mueller, Germany.  Leaving aside the Castrol Rankings, Mueller is perhaps the most statistically impressive player of 2010: only one off the Golden Boot with 3 goals, his 3 assists are good enough to tie Kaka for the tournament lead. (Those 6 total goals created are two more than anyone else has).  And Mueller has been just as impressive to the eye: his knifing runs and pure passes on the right wing have been a critical component to perhaps the most fluid attacking side in this World Cup.

Left (Center) Midfield: Mesut Ozil, Germany. The young Peter Lorre has had a tournament to kill for so far. Maybe the brightest new offensive star to emerge in South Africa, Ozil's creativity both on and off the ball offers German fans no end of pleasant surprises.  His torrid run down the left to set up Mueller's second goal against England has mostly been seen as an embarrassment for Gareth Barry, but it also showed Ozil's enormous class.  Along with Maicon and David Villa, he is on my short list of Golden Ball candidates for overall best player.  And scarily enough for everyone else in Europe, he's just 22.

Center Attacking Midfield: Lionel Messi, Argentina.  I swear (I think) this is not reputation talking.  In fact I've barely seen Messi play before this Cup, but I've still been dazzled by the dwarf from Rosario.  He hasn't scored, and technically has only earned one assist, but sometimes statistics are deceiving.  In every Argentina game I've seen (all but the Mexico contest) Messi has been at the absolute heart of every threatening Albiceleste attack.  As a manager of possession, a critical one-two threat with Higuain/Tevez/Aguero/etc every time he gets the ball, and a consistent fright to enemy keepers (I can think of two posts and one terrific Nigerian save so far), he's surely the best attacking player in this Cup not yet to score a goal.  Now, apparently, he's bet Diego Maradona double-or-nothing that he will score vs. Germany. I like his odds.

Striker: David Villa, Spain. The co-possessor of the Golden Boot, with 4 goals, Villa has been utterly spectacular in his four games.  And not just as a clinical striker, although he has surely done filled that role, as well: but unlike a Klose or Higuain or even Luis Fabiano, Villa doesn't just finish goals, he starts them, too.  An irritant on the left side without the ball, he is absolute monster with it.  As an opposing fan, there's no player I'd less rather see with the ball at the edge of the box.  If all goes well for Spain, he'll surely end with the Golden Ball as well as the Golden Boot.

Picture
Fabanio: death from 15 yards.
Striker: Luis Fabiano, Brazil.  I know Argentina's Gonzalo Higuain has actually been a bit more lethal than him (4 goals to 3; more shots on target); and I know one of his scores was really a double-hand-ball (It was also a fraudulent/awesome Pele impersonation).   Still, for me, Fabiano has been the best pure finisher of this tournament.  While a couple of Higain's goals have come on tap-ins, Fabiano has always had work to do, and he's done it well, convincingly, and usually in the corner of the net.

----------------

Attacking Sub: Gonzalo Higuain, Argentina.  It's really close between him and Fabiano.

Midfield Sub: Wesley Sneijder, Netherlands.
Sublime lead-bomb pass to Robben against Slovakia just edges him past Xavi and Kaka.

Defensive Sub: Gilberto Silva, Brazil. This "invisible wall" of a holding midfielder snuffs out opposing attacks with a minimum of fuss.  The infallible personification of Dunga's Brazil.

31 Comments
Alternate selections
7/1/2010 03:20:20

Your team is great but this one is clearly better:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TV7XZJfrJx0

Reply
Ajf 4 link
8/4/2010 12:15:26

A free man obtains knowledge from many sources 1 besides books .

Reply
Ajf 4 link
8/12/2010 11:47:49

A good beginning is half the battle.

Reply
Jordan 13 link
8/13/2010 16:44:31

Empty vessels make the most noise.

Reply
Jordan 13 link
8/15/2010 13:57:54

Have but few friends, though many acquaintances.

Reply
Jordan retro 4 link
8/16/2010 10:49:49

He is rich enough that wants nothing.

Reply
Ajf6 link
8/16/2010 12:35:02

Hope for the best and prepare for the worst.??

Reply
nike shox saya link
8/30/2010 12:47:24

Law is the crystallization of the habit and thought of society. (Woodrow Wilson, American president)

Reply
Supra TK Society link
8/31/2010 13:20:06

I am surprised to learn how much of information I accomplished on this specific issue. I m so very thankful of you. One thing I can say that, after reading this content I became preserved from the entire worthless search I should have executed on this specific topic. Your post is a genuine true blessing in disguise.

Reply
Air Jordan link
9/6/2010 10:35:31

Like the beautiful shoes or like comfortable shoes? Believe that many people will say like beautiful and comfortable shoes. You can enter into our website to see it, there is what you need. Thank you!

Reply
Jordan Flight 9 link
9/8/2010 17:01:35

Superb my good friend, what you say is best. I belive your weblog might be accepted by extra citizens and they are going to help you. http://www.twojordan.com/air-jordan-flight-9-108/

Reply
Jordan 11 link
9/14/2010 11:53:16

Knowledge and talent come only from practice.

Reply
Nike Air Max 2009 link
9/22/2010 17:12:37

So nice blog! But I have a suggestion that you can add some humorous language up to your article. Maybe you can write more better.

Reply
UGG Boots 5819 link
9/24/2010 20:00:47

I'm astonished to be conscious of how significantly of resources I acquired on this matter. I'm so especially thankful of you. The 1 point I could assert that, after looking by way of this article I became stored from the complete useless research I ought to have trained on this type of topic. Your post is a reliable fantastic matter in disguise.

Reply
Ugg Men's Ascot Slippers link
9/28/2010 18:33:20

There is known as a ugg bailey button ackground in all Ugg Men's Ascot Slippers. Slippers could be the satisfaction of ugg intage cardy emotion, drived from the ugg vintage mini previous and aimed in the long term. Males of genius are meteors destined to be consumed in lighting up their ugg boots sale internet century.

Reply
Air Force Ones link
10/6/2010 10:59:52

We often say someone is so beautiful, just as praise his/her soul in a degree. Because Courage and resolution are the spirit and soul of virtue. Do you think so?

Reply
jordan 23 link
10/18/2010 18:55:02

Should you would go up high, then use your own legs ! Usually do not let yourselves carried aloft; do not hold yourselves on other some people's backs and heads.

Reply
Nike Air Max 90 link
10/18/2010 19:13:27

Not because of change garments according to the season is not without distance without looking for you, Not because of you, Not from a busy and time and forget you, In the autumn is strong, I sincerely wish to you.

Reply
Nike Dunk SB link
10/19/2010 13:23:30

Wow, that you are impressive. I’ve been following factors of this remarkably rigid instruction system and I didn't even know! I've to become a all-natural no shock I appear and sense astounding a good deal around the time. It will bechallenging changing into this astounding is just not it!

Reply
Nike Shox Shoes link
10/31/2010 17:06:44

You actually provided us so detail information.that may be excellent for us to discover a little something.numerous comments I noticed almost decided with you.Excellent luck with your lifestyle.

Reply
Nike Air Max 90 link
10/31/2010 18:38:59

The journey of life are many, have smooth also have difficulties, Every busy who are all looking forward to reap the harvest are sweet, But also have bitter. Whether officer is poor, People is rich is flemingia all difficult to buy healthy physique, So I hope you will always happy.

Reply
Nike Shox TL link
11/2/2010 16:50:52

Immature love says:"I love you because I need you. "Mature love says:"I need you because I love you.

Reply
Nike Air Max 90 link
11/2/2010 17:43:04

Happiness always generous person concomitant with, Riches always accompanies with faith, Wisdom always and noble person concomitant, Charm will always be with sunshine person concomitant, Let all the wishes with you always.

Reply
cheap air yeezy link
11/25/2010 14:24:40

To laugh often and love much.

Reply
ugg classic tall link
12/8/2010 14:52:06

I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information <a href="http://www.uggtallboot.net/">ugg classic tall</a>I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post.<a href="http://www.shortuggboot.com/">short ugg boot</a> Thanks for sharing.

Reply
uggs for cheap link
1/11/2011 12:29:29

http://www.theuggbootscheap.com

Reply
uggboots link
1/12/2011 21:17:51

sell ugg boots on www.uggbootshop.org

Reply
flat shoes modern link
2/27/2013 14:59:31

This looks to be a very active website. How on earth do you keep up with approving all the comments?

Reply
flat thigh high boots link
2/27/2013 14:59:58


You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

Reply
akatsuki cosplay link
2/27/2013 15:00:48

So cool. What else can I say.Thanks once again for the great tunes.

Reply
baby girl names 2012 link
8/12/2013 21:37:42

The list given in your article is indeed one of the best line ups that football can field for a long time. The forwards and the defensive players are the best in the world. I am very happy to see this list on your article.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    An Extremely Intermittent Blog

    I love looking at this picture every time I log in.

    Picture

    Archives

    February 2013
    February 2012
    January 2012
    August 2011
    February 2011
    July 2010
    June 2010

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.